Monday, November 08, 2021
Omen
Homer, Iliad 12.243 (tr. Peter Green):
Newer› ‹Older
One omen is best, to fight in defense of your country!Bryan Hainsworth ad loc.:
εἷς οἰωνὸς ἄριστος, ἀμύνεσθαι περὶ πάτρης.
This famous verse is ejected by Lohmann, Reden 219, as upsetting the parallelism of Pouludamas' speech and Hektor's response. ἀμύνεσθαι περὶ πάτρης is formular, cf. 15.496, 24.500. At 15.497-8 defending the πάτρη is justified as defending ἄλοχος, παῖδες, οἶκος, and κλῆρος [wife, children, house, and estate], but that is Hektor exhorting lesser Trojans, and generals must appeal to the self-interest of their men not only to an altruistic sense of social obligation. Effectively Hektor's οἶκος is Troy. The well-rounded heroic character, pace Finley, World 116, acknowledges the claims of the community (cf. 310-28), but even in Hektor's own case those claims rank lower than his sense of honour and shame (cf. 22.99-130).Testimonialapparat in M.L. West's Teubner edition:
243 Metagenes fr. 19 K.-A. (parod.); Arist. Rh. 1395al3; Diod. 15.52.4 (Epaminondas loqu.); Cic. Att. 2.3.3; Plin. Ep. 1.18.4; Plut. Pyrrh. 29.4; [Plut.] Hom. 2.39.2,186.1; Alex. in Top. CAG ii(2).225.21; w5; Apthon. Progymn. 4; Nicol. Progymn. p.28.6 F.; Stob. 3.39.18; Zon. Fig. iii.167.7Sp.; sch Eur. Pho. 781; Choer. in Thd. ii.2.19, 8.35, 256.13; (-ἀμύν.) sch Aesch. Sept. 1011; 243a Plut. Mor. 333c; [Luc.] Dial. 58.5; sch Eur. Pho. 902