Friday, July 02, 2010
The Passion for Learning
Van Wyck Brooks, The Flowering of New England, 1815-1865 (New York: E.P. Dutton, 1936), pp. 175-177:
A Boston man had to be learned in something, and the passion for learning on the upper levels soon spread through all the other strata. Harvard set the pace. Thomas Wentworth Higginson was not unique as one who, at the time of his graduation, read French, Spanish, Italian, Latin and Greek, who later acquired German and Portuguese, Hebrew, a little Swedish, and always hoped for a chance to study Russian. Theodore Parker, the minister, somewhat older, the Roxbury Friar Tuck, the Lexington farmer's son who was able to carry a full barrel of cider, read Dutch, Danish and Russian, along with the others, Coptic, Chaldaic, Arabic, Ethiopic, and was found by one of his friends deep in a grammar of Mpongwe.* Here and there, some workman followed suit. Elihu Burritt of Worcester, the "learned blacksmith," was a typical figure of the moment. This well-known self-taught linguist who, as an apprentice, had kept a Greek grammar in the crown of his hat to study while he was casting brass cow-bells, who made a version of Longfellow in Sanskrit and mastered more than forty other tongues, toiling at the forge or in the evening, after a full day's work, affected no singularity, as he said. His aim was "to stand in the ranks of the workingmen of New England and beckon them onward and upward to the full stature of intellectual men." The noble-hearted Burritt† was not the only man of his kind. Many a boy walked thirty miles to Cambridge to feast his eyes on the sight of the college; and many a farmer's son, like Burritt, might have walked to Boston, a hundred and twenty miles, from New Britain, with two or three dollars and a silver watch tucked away in a handkerchief, hoping to catch a ship for India, where he could study Sanskrit. Sir Charles Lyell and Agassiz were surprised, when they arrived in Boston in the forties, by the universal interest in education. Lyell had never seen such crowds of workmen listening on winter nights to learned lectures on geology and zoology, Shakespeare and Milton. Agassiz was present at an assembly of three thousand mechanics, brought together to form a library and listening for two hours with rapt attention to a lecture on the advantages of reading. Dickens was impressed by the interests of the factory-girls of Lowell, a public that he knew so well in England. There were joint-stock pianos in their boarding-houses; the walls of the mills were covered with their poems; they subscribed to the British reviews; they had classes in German; they all seemed to know Paradise Lost by heart and talked about Wordsworth, Coleridge and Macaulay in the intervals of changing bobbins on the looms. [...] The fame of the Lowell Offering, which contained their writings,—humorous and pathetic tales, fairy-stories, poems,—travelled round the world.Hat tip: Peter Mottola.
* Theodore Parker's learning was famous in New England. T. W. Higginson related that he wished to find a certain reference in the Salic, Burgundian and Ripuarian codes before the codification of Charlemagne. Neither Sumner, Justice Gray nor Chief Justice Shaw could assist him on this occasion, but Sumner said, "Try Parker." Parker said at once, "Go to the Harvard Library, and on the fifth shelf in the fourth left-hand alcove you will find a small, thick quarto entitled 'Potgeiser: de Statu Servorum,' which will give you all the information you want." Higginson found his question answered there.—Chadwick, Theodore Parker.
† A passage from Elihu Burritt's diary, 1837: "Monday, June 18, headache; forty pages Cuvier's Theory of the Earth, sixty four pages French, eleven hours forging. Tuesday, sixty-five lines Hebrew, thirty pages of French, ten pages Cuvier's Theory, eight lines Syriac, ten ditto Danish, ten ditto Bohemian, nine ditto Polish, fifteen names of stars, ten hours forging. Wednesday, twenty-five lines Hebrew, fifty pages of astronomy, eleven hours forging. Thursday, fifty-five lines Hebrew, eight ditto Syriac, eleven hours forging. Friday, unwell, twelve hours forging," etc.
St. Francis of Assisi
Speculum Perfectionis (The Mirror of Perfection) 12.118, tr. by ? in Regis J. Armstrong et al., edd., Francis of Assisi: Early Documents (St. Bonaventure: Franciscan Institute of St. Bonaventure University, 2001), p. 366:
He also told the brother who cut and prepared the wood for the fire never to cut down the whole tree, but to cut the tree in such a way that one part always remained intact out of love for Him Who willed to accomplish our salvation on the wood of the cross.Latin from the edition by Paul Sabatier (Paris: Fischbacher, 1898), pp. 231-232:
Fratri etiam qui faciebat et parabat ligna pro igne dicebat ut nunquam totam arborem incideret ut talis arboris semper aliqua pars remaneret integra amore illius qui salutem nostram in ligno crucis voluit operari.Thomas of Celano, The Lives of S. Francis of Assisi, 2.124.165, tr. A.G. Ferrers Howell (London: Methuen & Co., 1908), p. 297:
When the brethren were cutting wood he forbad them to cut down a whole tree, so that it might have hope of sprouting again.Latin from S. Francisci Assisiensis Vita et Miracula ... auctore Fr. Thoma de Celano, ed. P. Eduardus Alenconiensis (Rome: Desclée, Lefebvre et Soc., 1906), p. 294:
Ligna caedentes fratres prohibet totam succidere arborem, ut spem habeat iterum pullulandi.
Labels: arboricide
Thursday, July 01, 2010
I'm Rich
Johann Peter Hebel, An Herrn Pfarrer Jäck (Letter to the Reverend Mr Jäck, tr. Leonard Forster):
It's true, sir, I have no tree of my own, I've got no house, I've got no sheep in the fold, no plough in the field, no beehive in my yard, no cat, no hen, and very often no money either. It makes no odds; even so, there's not a farmer in the village as rich as I am. You know how it's done; you make believe you've got it. And so I make believe I have it in sweet delusion, and wherever a tree is in bloom it's mine, and wherever a pig eats acorns it eats them in my woods.Hebel's poem reminds me of many passages by Thoreau, e.g. this from Walden:
And so, this way, I'm rich. But I'm even richer in the hay harvest, at reaping time, in glad autumn. I say: 'Come along now everybody, anyone who likes, and mow and reap and cut the grapes! I have had my pleasure of all this, refreshed my heart with all the scents, with all the beauty. The rest is yours. Take it home with you.'
S'isch wor, Her Jäck, i ha kei eigene Baum,
i ha kei Huus, i ha kei Schof im Stal,
kei Pflueg im Feld, kei Immestand im Hoff,
kei Chatz, kei Hüenli, mengmol au kei Geld.
'S macht nüt. 'S isch doch im ganze Dorf kei Buur
so rich as ich. Der wüsset wie me's macht.
Me meint, me heigs. So meini au, i heigs
im süesse Wahn, und wo ne Bäumli blüeiht,
's isch mi, und wo ne Feld voll Ähri schwankt,
's isch au mi; wo ne Säuli Eichle frisst,
es frisst sie us mim Wald.
So bin i rich. Doch richer bin i no
im Heuet, in der Erndt, im frohe Herbst.
I sag: Jez chömmer Lüt, wer will und mag,
und heuet, schnidet, hauet Trübli ab!
I ha mi Freud an allem gha, mi Herze
an alle Düften, aller Schöni g'labt.
Was übrig isch, isch euer. Tragets heim.
Why, the owner does not know it for many years when a poet has put his farm in rhyme, the most admirable kind of invisible fence, has fairly impounded it, milked it, skimmed it, and got all the cream, and left the farmer only the skimmed milk.
St. Amator, Bishop of Auxerre
Stephen the African, Life of St. Amator, Bishop of Auxerre (Vita Sancti Amatoris Episcopi Autissiodorensis), 4.24 = Acta Sanctorum, May 1 (Antwerp, 1680), T. I, pp. 50-60 (at p. 57, my translation):
Amator died in 418. Surprisingly, in view of the excerpt above, Germanus (also known as Germain) succeded Amator as bishop of Auxerre. The Life of St. Amator by Stephen the African can be dated to the late sixth century, as it is mentioned in correspondence between Stephen and Germanus’ successor as bishop of Auxerre, Aunarius (561-604): see Constance B. Bouchard, "Episcopal Gesta and the Creation of a Useful Past in Ninth-Century Auxerre," Speculum 84 (2009) 1-35 (note 50 on p. 12). Bouchard discusses Amator generally on pp. 11-15, Germanus on pp. 15-25. Also, on Germanus' civil career, see Prosopography of the Later Roman Empire, Vol. 2 (A.D. 395-527), ed. J.R. Martindale (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1980; rpt. 2006), pp. 504-505.
When these things were happening, one Germanus by name, born of noble seed, was governing the territory of Auxerre under his own control. He was accustomed to give himself up to youthful pursuits rather than to pay attention to the Christian religion. Therefore, constantly devoted to the chase, he very often used to take a quantity of wild beasts by traps and the activity of his skill. Now there was a pear tree in the middle of the city, of a most pleasing delightfulness. On its branches Germanus used to hang the heads of the beasts caught by him, to win applause for his great hunting.The Latin:
Amator, the distinguished bishop of the same city, often used to urge him with the following utterances: "I beg you, most illustrious gentleman, stop pursuing this foolishness, which is odious to Christans and worthy of imitation by pagans. This is an act of idolatrous worship, not of dignified Christian tradition." And although the worthy man of God continued unceasingly, nevertheless Germanus was by no means willing to agree or to obey his advice. The man of the Lord again and again exhorted him not only to stop this evil custom which he had taken up, but also to destroy the tree root and branch, lest it be an object of resentment to Christians. But Germanus was to no degree willing to lend a kindly ear to Amator's advice.
Around the time of this attempt at persuasion, one day the aforementioned Germanus departed from the city to his own estates. Then the blessed Amator, waiting for the opportunity, cut down the accursed tree into logs. Lest it serve as a reminder to the unbelievers, he at once ordered the tree to be burned with fire. The animal heads, which hung down and served as a reminder of a trophy of the hunt, as it were, he ordered thrown far from the city walls. Immediately someone, making his way to an audience with the oft-mentioned Germanus, inflamed his mind with the story, increased his rage with recommendations, and made him cruel, to the point that, forgetful of holy religion, in whose ceremonies and duties he had been consecrated, he threatened death against the most holy man.
Eo autem tempore quo haec gesta sunt, Germanus quidam nomine, nobili germine procreatus, territorium Autissiodorense visitatione propria gubernat: cui mos erat tirunculorum potius industriis indulgere, quam Christianae religioni operam dare. Is ergo assidue venatui invigilans, ferarum copiam insidiis, atque artis strenuitate frequentissime capiebat. Erat autem arbor pyrus in urbe media, amoenitate gratissima, ad cujus ramusculos ferarum ab eo deprehensarum capita pro admiratione venationis nimiae dependebant.I'm dissatisfied with my translation. First, these post-classical texts contain terms which are probably technical, but whose shades of meaning elude the non-specialist such as me. Perhaps territorium is such a term, and certainly visitatio is. I translated the former as territory, the latter as control, although visitatio is strictly speaking a visit of inspection, apparently more usual in an ecclesiastical context than in a secular or civil one, as here. See J.F. Niermeyer and C. Van de Kieft, Mediae Latitinatis Lexicon Minus, rev. J.W.J. Burgers, Vol. 2 (Leiden: Brill, 2002), p. 1449. Second, my rendering of cum caudicibus doesn't seem right. Third, I softened the mixed metaphor in gressus suos ad aures saepedicti Germani retorquens (you don't normally turn your steps to someone's ears).
Quem celebris ejusdem civitatis Amator episcopus, his frequens compellabat eloquiis: Desine, quaeso, vir bonorum splendidissime, haec jocularia, quae Christianis offensa, Paganis vero imitanda sunt, exercere. Hoc opus idololatricae culturae est, non Christianae elegantissimae disciplinae. Et licet hoc vir Deo dignus indesinenter perageret, ille tamen nullo modo admonenti se acquiescere voluit aut obedire. Vir autem Domini iterum atque iterum eum hortabatur, ut non solum a consuetudine mala arrepta discederet, verum etiam et ipsam arborem, ne Christianis offendiculum esset, radicitus exstirparet. Sed ille nullatenus aurem placidam applicare voluit admonenti. In hujus ergo persuasionis tempore, quadam die praefatus Germanus ex urbe in praedia sui juris secessit.
Tunc B. Amator, opportunitatem opperiens, sacrilegam arborem cum caudicibus abscidit: et, ne aliqua ejus incredulis esset memoria, igni concremandam illico deputavit: oscilla vero, quae tanquam trophaei cujusdam certaminis umbram dependentia ostentabant, longius a civitatis terminis projici praecepit. Protinus autem [aliquis] gressus suos ad aures saepedicti Germani retorquens, dictis animum incendit, atque iram suis suasionibus exaggerans, ferocem effecit: ita ut oblitus sanctae religionis, cujus jam fuerat ritu atque munere consecratus, mortem beatissimo viro minitaret.
Amator died in 418. Surprisingly, in view of the excerpt above, Germanus (also known as Germain) succeded Amator as bishop of Auxerre. The Life of St. Amator by Stephen the African can be dated to the late sixth century, as it is mentioned in correspondence between Stephen and Germanus’ successor as bishop of Auxerre, Aunarius (561-604): see Constance B. Bouchard, "Episcopal Gesta and the Creation of a Useful Past in Ninth-Century Auxerre," Speculum 84 (2009) 1-35 (note 50 on p. 12). Bouchard discusses Amator generally on pp. 11-15, Germanus on pp. 15-25. Also, on Germanus' civil career, see Prosopography of the Later Roman Empire, Vol. 2 (A.D. 395-527), ed. J.R. Martindale (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1980; rpt. 2006), pp. 504-505.
Labels: arboricide
The Study of German
Charles G. Leland, To a Friend Studying German, from The Breitmann Ballads, new ed. (London: Trübner & Co., 1889), pp. 55-57 (motto and notes omitted):
Vill'st dou learn die Deutsche Sprache?Related post: The German Language.
Denn set it on your card,
Dat all the nouns have shenders,
Und de shenders all are hard.
Dere ish also dings called pronoms,
Vitch id's shoost ash vell to know;
Boot ach! de verbs or time-words—
Dey'll work you bitter woe.
Will'st dou learn de Deutsche Sprache?
Denn you allatag moost go
To sinfonies, sonatas,
Or an oratorio.
Vhen you dinks you knows 'pout musik,
More ash any other man,
Be sure de soul of Deutschland
Into your soul ish ran.
Will'st dou learn de Deutsche Sprache?
Dou moost eat apout a peck
A week, of stinging sauerkraut,
Und sefen pfoundts of speck.
Mit Gott knows vot in vinegar,
Und deuce knows vot in rum:
Dis ish de only cerdain vay
To make de accents coom.
Will'st dou learn de Deutsche Sprache?
Brepare dein soul to shtand
Soosh sendences ash ne'er vas heardt
In any oder land.
Till dou canst make parentheses
Intwisted—ohne zahl—
Dann wirst du erst Deutschfertig seyn,
For a languashe ideál.
Will'st dou learn de Deutsche Sprache?
Du must mitout an fear
Trink afery tay an gallon dry,
Of foamin Sherman bier.
Und de more you trinks, pe certain,
More Deutsch you'll surely pe;
For Gambrinus ish de Emperor
Of de whole of Germany.
Will'st dou learn de Deutsche Sprache?
Be sholly, brav, und treu,
For dat veller ish kein Deutscher
Who ish not a sholly poy.
Find out vot means Gemüthlichkeit,
Und do it mitout fail,
In Sang und Klang dein Lebenlang,
A brick—ganz kreuzfidél.
Will'st dou learn de Deutsche Sprache?
If a shendleman dou art,
Denn shtrike right indo Deutschland,
Und get a schveetes heart.
From Schwabenland or Sachsen
Vhere now dis writer pees;
Und de bretty girls all wachsen
Shoost like aepples on de drees.
Boot if dou bee'st a laty,
Denn on de oder hand,
Take a blonde moustachioed lofer
In de vine green Sherman land.
Und if you shoost kit married
(Vood mit vood soon makes a vire),
You'll learn to sprechen Deutsch mein kind,
Ash fast ash you tesire.
Wednesday, June 30, 2010
Black Raspberries
Berries grow behind my house. When ripe they look like blackberries, but they're actually black raspberries, Rubus occidentalis.
For the genus see Nathaniel Lord Britton and Addison Brown, An Illustrated Flora of the Northern United States, Canada and the British Possessions, 2nd ed. (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1913; rpt. New York: Dover, 1970), II, 275:

Rubus occidentalis
For the genus see Nathaniel Lord Britton and Addison Brown, An Illustrated Flora of the Northern United States, Canada and the British Possessions, 2nd ed. (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1913; rpt. New York: Dover, 1970), II, 275:
Perennial herbs, shrubs or trailing vines, often prickly, with alternate simple lobed or 3-7-foliolate leaves, the stipules adnate to the petiole. Flowers terminal or axillary, solitary, racemose or panicled, white, pink or purple, perfect or sometimes dioecious. Calyx persistent, not bracted, deeply 5-parted, its tube short and broad. Petals 5, deciduous. Stamens ∞, usually numerous, inserted on the calyx, distinct. Carpels ∞, rarely few, inserted on a convex or elongated receptacle, ripening into drupelets and forming an aggregate fruit, which in many species is edible, sweet and delicious, in others sour, or nearly tasteless. Ovules 2, one abortive. Style nearly terminal, slender. Seed pendulous. [The ancient name of the bramble, from ruber, red.]For the species (common name thimble-berry), see Britton and Brown, II, 277:
Very glaucous, stems cane-like, recurved, often rooting at the tip, sometimes 10°-12° long, sparingly armed with small hooked prickles, rarely slightly glandular-bristly above. Stipules setaceous, deciduous; leaves pinnately 3-foliolate (rarely 5-foliolate); leaflets ovate, acuminate, coarsely incised-serrate, very white-pubescent beneath; flowers as in the preceding species [i.e. flowers 4"-5" broad]; inflorescence corymbose, compact, usually only terminal; pedicels short, ascending or erect in fruit; fruit purple-black (rarely yellow), depressed-hemispheric.Thoreau mentions black raspberries under the common name thimble-berries, e.g. Journal (July 16, 1851):
New Brunswick to Quebec, Ontario, Georgia and Missouri. Ascends to 3000 ft. in Virginia. The original of the Gregg, Hilborn and other raspberries. May-June. Fruit ripe July. Called also scotch-cap and black-cap. Purple raspberry. Black-berry.
The black thimble-berry is an honest, homely berry, now drying up as usual. I used to have a pleasant time stringing them on herd's-grass stems, tracing the wallsides for them.Journal (December 1, 1856):
I see great thimble-berry bushes rising above the snow, with still a rich, rank bloom on them, as in July. Hypaethral mildew, elysian fungus! To see the bloom on a thimble-berry stem lasting into midwinter! What a salve that would make, collected and boxed!I usually eat black raspberries plain or with a little milk or cream, but this year I may try to make black raspberry liqueur as well.

An Epigram by Thomas More
Thomas More (1478-1535), Epigram 254 (Medicinae ad tollendos foetores anhelitus provenientes a cibis quibusdam,i.e. Cures to remove bad breath arising from certain foods):
Sectile ne taetros porrum tibi spiret odores,Translated by John Harington (1560-1612) as Of Garlick. To my Ladie Rogers:
protinus a porro fac mihi caepe vores.
Denuo foetorem si vis depellere caepae,
hoc facile efficient allia mansa tibi.
Spiritus at si post etiam gravis allia restat,
aut nihil, aut tantum tollere merda potest.
If Leekes you like, and doe the smell disleeke,As others have noted, "go looke" is the equivalent of a series of asterisks. In order to rhyme with the preceding line, "a turd" must be read (which matches More's "merda").
Eate Onions, and you shall not smell the Leeke:
If you of Onions would the sent expell,
Eate Garlick, that will drowne th' Onyons smell.
But sure, gainst Garlicks sauour, at one word,
I know but one receit, what's that? (go looke).
Labels: noctes scatologicae
Tuesday, June 29, 2010
The Life of the Mind
Theodore Dalrymple, "The Brothers Grim," First Things (June/July 2010):
[H]e does not seem spiteful, malicious, or petty (common characteristics of those who lead the life of the mind).
A Reason Fair
There seem to be several versions extant of The Toper's Apology by Charles Morris (1745-1838). The following is from Lyra Urbanica; or, The Social Effusions of the Celebrated Captain Charles Morris of the Late Life-Guards, vol. I (London: Richard Bentley, 1840), pp. 73-76:
Lyra Urbanica contains many delightful verses in the Anacreontic vein, and I may post more of them in future. According to a disapproving notice by S. Austin Allibone in A Critical Dictionary of English Literature and British and American Authors Living and Deceased, Vol. II (Philadelphia: J.B. Lippincott Company, 1891), p. 1321, Captain Charles Morris

Captain Charles Morris
Related posts:
I'm often ask'd by plodding souls,To my ear, the fifth stanza has the ring of one of A.E. Housman's lyrics. There is a clever translation of The Toper's Apology by R.Y. Tyrrell "into a Greek song in the metre of the famous scolion about Harmodius and Aristogiton" in The Classical Review 7 (1893) 368-369.
And men of crafty tongue,
What joy I take in draining bowls
And tippling all night long.
Now, though these cautious knaves I scorn,
For once I'll not disdain
To tell them why I sit till morn,
And fill my glass again;
'Tis by the glow my bumper gives,
Life's picture's mellow made;
The fading light then brightly lives,
And softly sinks the shade.
Some happier tint still rises there,
With every drop I drain
And that I think's a reason fair
To fill my glass again.
My Muse, too, when her wings are dry
No frolic flight will take;
But round a bowl she'll dip and fly,
Like swallows round a lake.
Then, if the nymph will have her share
Before she'll bless her swain
Why that I think's a reason fair
To fill my glass again.
In life I've rung all changes too,
Run every pleasure down,
Tried each extreme of Fancy through,
And lived with half the town;
For me there's nothing new or rare
Till wine deceives my brain
And that I think's a reason fair
To fill my glass again.
Then, many a lad I liked is dead,
And many a lass grown old;
And as the lesson strikes my head,
My weary heart grows cold.
But wine, awhile, drives off despair,
Nay, bids a hope remain
And that I think's a reason fair
To fill my glass again.
Then, hipp'd and vex'd at England's state
In these convulsive days,
I can't endure the ruin'd fate,
My sober eye surveys.
But 'midst the bottle's dazzling glare,
I see the gloom less plain
And that I think's a reason fair
To fill my glass again.
I find, too, when I stint my glass,
And sit with sober air,
I'm prosed by some dull reasoning ass,
Who treads the path of care;
Or, harder tax'd, I'm forced to bear
Some coxcomb's fribbling strain
And that I think's a reason fair
To fill my glass again.
Nay, don't we see Love's fetters, too,
With different holds entwine?
While nought but death can some undo,
There's some give way to wine.
With me the lighter head I wear
The lighter hangs the chain
And that I think's a reason fair
To fill my glass again.
And now I'll tell, to end my song,
At what I most repine:
This cursed war, or right or wrong,
Is war against all wine;
Nay, Port, they say, will soon be rare
As juice of France or Spain
And that I think's a reason fair
To fill my glass again.
Lyra Urbanica contains many delightful verses in the Anacreontic vein, and I may post more of them in future. According to a disapproving notice by S. Austin Allibone in A Critical Dictionary of English Literature and British and American Authors Living and Deceased, Vol. II (Philadelphia: J.B. Lippincott Company, 1891), p. 1321, Captain Charles Morris
served in the British army during the American Revolution, in the 17th Regiment of Foot; on his return to England he exchanged to a dragoon-regiment, and subsequently entered the Life-Guards. He married the widow of Sir William Stanhope. He was a great favourite in fashionable society, for the amusement of which he wrote many bacchanalian songs and uttered many witty sayings.Morris is such a minor figure that he doesn't even merit an entry in Margaret Drabble, The Oxford Companion to English Literature, 5th ed. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1985). But his graceful verses are pleasing, and he deserves to be rescued from oblivion.

Related posts:
Labels: nunc est bibendum
Monday, June 28, 2010
Without a Human Presence
Edward Abbey, Desert Solitaire (chapter Bedrock and Paradox):
In deep stillness, in a somber solemn light, these beings stand, these fins of sandstone hollowed out by time, the juniper trees so shaggy, tough and beautiful, the dead or dying pinyon pines, the little shrubs of rabbitbrush and blackbrush, the dried-up stalks of asters and sunflowers gone to seed, the black-rooted silver-blue sage. How difficult to imagine this place without a human presence; how necessary. I am almost prepared to believe that this sweet virginal primitive land will be grateful for my departure and the absence of the tourists, will breathe metaphorically a collective sigh of relieflike a whisper of windwhen we are all and finally gone and the place and its creations can return to their ancient procedures unobserved and undisturbed by the busy, anxious, brooding consciousness of man.Abbey's musings are mild compared with this screed by the outrageous Fred Reed, in which he pleads the case for human extinction:
Grateful for our departure? One more expression of human vanity. The finest quality of this stone, these plants and animals, this desert landscape is the indifference manifest to our presence, our absence, our coming, our staying or our going. Whether we live or die is a matter of absolutely no concern whatsoever to the desert. Let men in their madness blast every city on earth into black rubble and envelop the entire planet in a cloud of lethal gasthe canyons and hills, the springs and rocks will still be here, the sunlight will filter through, water will form and warmth shall be upon the land and after sufficient time, no matter how long, somewhere, living things will emerge and join and stand once again, this time perhaps to take a different and better course. I have seen the place called Trinity, in New Mexico, where our wise men exploded the first atomic bomb and the heat of the blast fused sand into a greenish glassalready the grass has returned, and the cactus and the mesquite. On this bedrock of animal faith I take my stand, close by the old road that leads eventually out of the valley of paradox.
We breed incontinently as flies, spread like impetigo, and burn and cut and poison and bulldoze. To what end? Why is a lake, solitary and wild, made better by a subdivision of six thousand units, with unnecessary children littering the pavement with plastic bottles while their parents gawp at televisions? Yes, I know. It is Progress. I just don't see why it is.Related post: Misanthropy.
I wonder what the world must have been a million years ago, before our sordid race of moralizing apes arose to invent the sewage outfall, before we learned to perforate the floor of oceans and poison whole seas with the bile of the inner earth. Yes, I know of property rights and the desperate need for the economy to grow, though to what end I cannot imagine. It seems to me that we should strive to shrink the economy. Pelicans and seals do not grow their economies and, I think, seldom use bulldozers. Yet they prosper.
The Way We Live Now
I just finished reading Anthony Trollope's novel The Way We Live Now. It was first published 135 years ago, but its description of financial shenanigans seems very up-to-date in 2010. The villain Augustus Melmotte reminds me of no one so much as Bernie Madoff, except that the former had the decency to kill himself with prussic acid when his crime was discovered, while the latter is now a guest at taxpayers' expense in Butner Federal Prison, affectionately known to its inmates as Camp Fluffy. Here are some excerpts from The Way We Live Now.
Chapter 2 (example of asyndetic, privative adjectives):
Chapter 2 (example of asyndetic, privative adjectives):
fathomless, bottomless, endlessChapter 6:
Land is a luxury, and of all luxuries is the most costly.Chapter 8:
Roger Carbury did not quite believe in the forgiveness of injuries. If you pardon all the evil done to you, you encourage others to do you evil! If you give your cloak to him who steals your coat, how long will it be, before your shirt and trousers will go also?Chapter 11:
There is the review intended to sell a book,which comes out immediately after the appearance of the book, or sometimes before it; the review which gives reputation, but does not affect the sale, and which comes a little later; the review which snuffs a book out quietly; the review which is to raise or lower the author a single peg, or two pegs, as the case may be; the review which is suddenly to make an author, and the review which is to crush him.Chapter 16 (boodying = sulking):
'He is a man of that kind,so stiff and stubborn and old-fashioned that nothing will change him. He will go on boodying over it, till he will become an old misanthrope.'Chapter 30:
But then dear Roger was old-fashioned, and knew nothing of people as they are now. He lived in a world which, though slow, had been good in its way; but which, whether bad or good, had now passed away.Chapter 39:
If one has to be hung on a given day, would it not be well to be hung as soon after waking as possible? I can fancy that the hangman would hardly come early enough. And if one had to be hung in a given week, would not one wish to be hung on the first day of the week, even at the risk of breaking one's last Sabbath day in this world? Whatever be the misery to be endured, get it over. The horror of every agony is in its anticipation.Chapter 42:
'If men were equal to-morrow and all wore the same coats, they would wear different coats the next day.'Chapter 44 (cf. "There is no God but Allah and Mohammed is his Prophet"):
It seemed that there was but one virtue in the world, commercial enterprise,and that Melmotte was its prophet.Chapter 44 (too big to fail):
'There are a good many who say that Melmotte will burst up.'Chapter 46:
'I don't believe it,' said Lord Alfred. 'They don't know what they're talking about. There are too many in the same boat to let him burst up. It would be the bursting up of half London.'
'People live now in a way that I don't comprehend.'Chapter 50:
There is an intoxication that makes merry in the midst of affliction,and there is an intoxication that banishes affliction by producing oblivion. But again there is an intoxication which is conscious of itself though it makes the feet unsteady, and the voice thick, and the brain foolish; and which brings neither mirth nor oblivion.Chapter 53 (example of rhetorical device known as climax or ladder):
Mr Longestaffe in the meantime had progressed from weariness to impatience, from impatience to ill-humour, and from ill-humour to indignation.Chapter 54:
He was one of those men whom success never mollified, whose enjoyment of a point gained always demanded some hoarse note of triumph from his own trumpet.Chapter 55:
'A failure! Of course he's a failure, whether rich or poor;a miserable imposition, a hollow vulgar fraud from beginning to end,too insignificant for you and me to talk of, were it not that his position is a sign of the degeneracy of the age.'Chapter 55:
'Taking society as a whole, the big and the little, the rich and the poor, I think that it grows better from year to year, and not worse. I think, too, that they who grumble at the times, as Horace did, and declare that each age is worse than its forerunner, look only at the small things beneath their eyes, and ignore the course of the world at large.'Chapter 55 (quotation unidentified in the Penguin Classics edition, note on p. 776, but it's from Horace, Epodes 4.20):
hoc, hoc tribuno militumChapter 62:
When such rumours are spread abroad, they are always believed. There is an excitement and a pleasure in believing them. Reasonable hesitation at such a moment is dull and phlegmatic. If the accused one be near enough to ourselves to make the accusation a matter of personal pain, of course we disbelieve. But, if the distance be beyond this, we are almost ready to think that anything may be true of anybody.Chapter 64 (example of rhetorical device known as praeteritio):
'I scorn,' said he, 'to say anything against the personal character of a political opponent, which I am not in a position to prove. I make no allusion, and have made no allusion, to reports which were circulated yesterday about him, and which I believe were originated in the City. They may be false or they may be true.'Chapter 64:
Masses of men will almost feel that a certain amount of injustice ought to be inflicted on their betters, so as to make things even, and will persuade themselves that a criminal should be declared to be innocent, because the crime committed has had a tendency to oppress the rich and pull down the mighty from their seats. Some few years since, the basest calumnies that were ever published in this country, uttered by one of the basest men that ever disgraced the country, levelled, for the most part, at men of whose characters and services the country was proud, were received with a certain amount of sympathy by men not themselves dishonest, because they who were thus slandered had received so many good things from Fortune, that a few evil things were thought to be due to them.Chapter 64:
'A child has such a hold upon his mother. When her reason has bade her to condemn him, her heart will not let her carry out the sentence.'Chapter 67:
But he was chiefly tormented in these days by the want of amusement. He had so spent his life hitherto that he did not know how to get through a day in which no excitement was provided for him. He never read. Thinking was altogether beyond him. And he had never done a day's work in his life. He could lie in bed. He could eat and drink. He could smoke and sit idle. He could play cards; and could amuse himself with women,the lower the culture of the women, the better the amusement. Beyond these things the world had nothing for him.Chapter 69:
It was astonishing, some people said, what things attorneys would do in these days!Chapter 70:
Throughout the world, the more wrong a man does, the more indignant is he at wrong done to him.Chapter 78:
'Do nothing for you! Haven't you got a home to live in, and clothes to wear, and a carriage to go about in,and books to read if you choose to read them? What do you expect?'Chapter 84:
'Everybody is a burden to other people. It is the way of life.'Chapter 84:
'Love is like any other luxury. You have no right to it unless you can afford it.'Chapter 93:
To a man not accustomed to thinking there is nothing in the world so difficult as to think. After some loose fashion we turn over things in our mind and ultimately reach some decision, guided probably by our feelings at the last moment rather than by any process of ratiocination;and then we think that we have thought. But to follow out one argument to an end, and then to found on the base so reached the commencement of another, is not common to us.Chapter 96 (quotation unidentified according to the Penguin Classics edition, note on p. 779, but it's from The Toper's Apology by Charles Morris (1745-1838)):
'In life I've rung all changes through,Chapter 100:
Run every pleasure down,
'Midst each excess of folly too,
And lived with half the town.'
As to giving his coat to the thief who had taken his cloak,he told himself that were he and others to be guided by that precept honest industry would go naked in order that vice and idleness might be comfortably clothed. If any one stole his cloak he would certainly put that man in prison as soon as possible and not commence his lenience till the thief should at any rate affect to be sorry for his fault.
Saturday, June 26, 2010
As You Like It
Excerpts from Shakespeare, As You Like It:
1.2.92:
1.2.92:
...news-crammed...1.3.12 (Rosalind):
O, how full of briers is this working-day world!2.1.12-14 (Duke Senior):
Sweet are the uses of adversity,2.3.15-16 (Adam):
Which, like the toad, ugly and venomous,
Wears yet a precious jewel in his head.
O, what a world is this, when what is comely2.3.51-57 (Adam):
Envenoms him that bears it!
Though I look old, yet I am strong and lusty;2.4.16-17 (Touchstone):
For in my youth I never did apply
Hot and rebellious liquors in my blood,
Nor did not with unbashful forehead woo
The means of weakness and debility;
Therefore my age is as a lusty winter,
Frosty, but kindly.
When I was at home I was in a better place; but travellers must be content.2.5.12-13 (Jaques):
I can suck melancholy out of a song, as a weasel sucks eggs.2.6.5 (Orlando):
Live a little; comfort a little; cheer thyself a little.2.7.60-64 (Jaques):
Give me leave2.7.204-208 (Duke Senior, add to collection about children resembling fathers):
To speak my mind, and I will through and through
Cleanse the foul body of th' infected world,
If they will patiently receive my medicine.
If that you were the good Sir Rowland's son,3.2.72-76 (Corin):
As you have whisper'd faithfully you were,
And as mine eye doth his effigies witness
Most truly limn'd and living in your face,
Be truly welcome hither.
Sir, I am a true labourer: I earn that I eat, get that I wear; owe no man hate, envy no man's happiness; glad of other men's good, content with my harm; and the greatest of my pride is to see my ewes graze and my lambs suck.3.2.191-193 (Celia):
O wonderful, wonderful, most wonderful wonderful, and yet again wonderful, and after that, out of all whooping!3.2.248-249 (Rosalind):
Do you not know I am a woman? When I think, I must speak.3.2.275-276 (Jaques):
Will you sit down with me? and we two will rail against our mistress the world, and all our misery.3.5.62-63 (Rosalind disguised):
Down on your knees,4.1.3-4 (Rosalind disguised and Jaques):
And thank heaven, fasting, for a good man's love.
Ros. They say you are a melancholy fellow.4.1.10-19 (Jaques):
Jaq. I am so; I do love it better than laughing.
I have neither the scholar's melancholy, which is emulation; nor the musician's, which is fantastical; nor the courtier's, which is proud; nor the soldier's, which is ambitious; nor the lawyer's, which is politic; nor the lady's, which is nice; nor the lover's, which is all these; but it is a melancholy of mine own, compounded of many simples, extracted from many objects, and, indeed, the sundry contemplation of my travels; in which my often rumination wraps me in a most humorous sadness.4.1.101-102 (Rosalind):
Men have died from time to time, and worms have eaten them, but not for love.5.4.83-85 (Touchstone):
I did dislike the cut of a certain courtier's beard; he sent me word, if I said his beard was not cut well, he was in the mind it was. This is call'd the Retort Courteous. If I sent him word again it was not well cut, he would send me word he cut it to please himself. This is call'd the Quip Modest. If again it was not well cut, he disabled my judgment. This is call'd the Reply Churlish. If again it was not well cut, he would answer I spake not true. This is call'd the Reproof Valiant. If again it was not well cut, he would say I lie. This is call'd the Countercheck Quarrelsome. And so to the Lie Circumstantial and the Lie Direct.5.4.105-106 (Touchstone):
Your If is the only peace-maker; much virtue in If.
Thursday, June 24, 2010
Romeo and Juliet
Excerpts from Shakespeare, Romeo and Juliet:
1.1.150-156 (Montague, speaking of the secretive Romeo):
1.1.150-156 (Montague, speaking of the secretive Romeo):
But he, his own affections' counsellor,1.1.234 (Romeo):
Is to himselfI will not say how true,
But to himself so secret and so close,
So far from sounding and discovery,
As is the bud bit with an envious worm
Ere he can spread his sweet leaves to the air
Or dedicate his beauty to the sun.
O, teach me how I should forget to think!1.2.62-64 (servingman and Romeo):
Serv. I pray, sir, can you read?1.4.14-16 (Romeo, to be said when asked to dance):
Rom. Ay, mine own fortune in my misery.
Serv. Perhaps you have learned it without book.
Not I, believe me. You have dancing shoes2.1.22-23 (Mercutio, part of an oath):
With nimble soles; I have a soul of lead
So stakes me to the ground I cannot move.
By her fine foot, straight leg, and quivering thigh,2.2.1 (Romeo):
And the demesnes that there adjacent lie...
He jests at scars that never felt a wound.2.3.17-20 (Friar Lawrence):
For naught so vile that on the earth doth live2.3.34-40 (Friar Lawrence to Romeo):
But to the earth some special good doth give;
Nor aught so good but, strain'd from that fair use,
Revolts from true birth, stumbling on abuse.
What early tongue so sweet saluteth me?2.3.101 (Friar Lawrence):
Young son, it argues a distempered head
So soon to bid good morrow to thy bed.
Care keeps his watch in every old man's eye,
And where care lodges sleep will never lie;
But where unbruisèd youth with unstuff'd brain
Doth couch his limbs, there golden sleep doth reign.
Wisely, and slow. They stumble that run fast.2.5.16-17 (Juliet):
But old folks, many feign as they were dead,3.1.17-25 (Mercutio to Benvolio):
Unwieldy, slow, heavy and pale as lead.
Thou! why, thou wilt quarrel with a man that hath a hair more or a hair less in his beard than thou hast. Thou wilt quarrel with a man for cracking nuts, having no other reason but because thou hast hazel eyes. What eye but such an eye would spy out such a quarrel? Thy head is as full of quarrels as an egg is full of meat; and yet thy head hath been beaten as addle as an egg for quarrelling.3.1.207 (Prince):
Mercy but murders, pardoning those that kill.3.3.13-15 (Romeo):
Ha, banishment? Be merciful, say "death,"3.3.58 (Friar Lawrence):
For exile hath more terror in his look,
Much more than death. Do not say "banishment."
...Adversity's sweet milk, philosophy...3.3.95 (Nurse, chiasmus):
Blubb'ring and weeping, weeping and blubb'ring.3.5.74-75 (Lady Capulet):
Some grief shows much of love;4.2.6-7 (servingman):
But much of grief shows still some want of wit.
Marry, sir, 'tis an ill cook that cannot lick his own fingers.4.5.55-60 (Nurse, suitable to be said on many occasions):
O woe, O woeful, woeful, woeful day!
Most lamentable day, most woeful day
That ever, ever I did yet behold!
O day, O day, O day, O hateful day!
Never was seen so black a day as this!
O woeful day, O woeful day!
St. Columba
Betha Colaim Chille: Life of Columcille, Compiled by Manus O'Donnell in 1532. Edited and translated from manuscript Rawlinson B.514 in the Bodleian Library, Oxford... by A. O'Kelleher and G. Schoepperle (Chicago: Irish Foundation Series of America, 1918), Gaelic on pp. 82, 84, English translation on facing pp. 83, 85:
89. Herein is seen how greatly Columcille loved Derry, and how loth he was to cut or fell the grove of trees there. When he was building the oratory that men call today Dubhreigles, because of the nearness of that grove, he could not find a place to build the oratory in such wise that the front of the altar should be toward the east. And so loth was he to cut down the grove, that he bade the side of the oratory be toward the east. In proof hereof the altar where he was wont to say the mass is on the side thereof, and it is manifest to all today that thus is the site of the oratory. And he charged his successors to chop no tree that fell of itself or that was blown down by the wind, till the end of nine days, and then to divide it among all the folk of the place, good and bad; a third part of it to be put in the guest-house for the guests, and a tenth part as a share for the poor. And this is the quatrain he made after going into exile in Alba, and it proveth that naught was so grievous to him as to cut the grove of Derry.Cf. also these lines from a poem in Gaelic attributed to St. Columba, edited and translated by William Reeves among the notes to his edition of The Life of St. Columba, Founder of Hy; written by Adamnan (Dublin: Irish Archaeological and Celtic Society, 1857), pp. 285-289 (at 288):"Though I am affrighted, truly,
By death and by Hell;
I am more affrighted, frankly,
By the sound of an ax in Derry in the West."
The reason why I love Derry is,
For its quietness, for its purity,
Crowded full of heaven's angels
Is every leaf of the oaks of Derry.
My Derry, my little oak-grove,
My dwelling, and my little cell;
O eternal God, in heaven above,
Woe be to him who violates it!
Labels: arboricide
Wednesday, June 23, 2010
Miscellany
Asa Gray (1810-1888) seems to have been the first to use the word arboricide in English, but we should also give credit to Abraham Cowley (1618-1667), who in his Libri Plantarum 2.117-118 wrote:
Agennius Urbicus, in Brian Campbell, The Writings of the Roman Land Surveyors: Introduction, Text, Translation and Commentary (London: Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies, 2000), pp. 70 (Latin) and 71 (translation):
Gregory the Great (540-604), Dialogues 2.8, tr. by Hilary Costello and Eoin de Bhaldraithe in Gregory the Great, The Life of St. Benedict, tr. (Petersham: St. Bede's Publications, 1993; rpt. 2003), p. 64:
Sermon of St. Eligius (588-660), Bishop of Noyon-Tournai, quoted in Dado (aka Audoen or Ouen or Owen), Life of St. Eligius 2.16, tr. Jo Ann McNamara:
Council of Nantes (7th or 9th century?), c. 18, in Jacques Sirmond, ed. Concilia Antiqua Galliae (Paris, 1629; rpt. Aalen: Scientia, 1970), vol. 3, p. 607 (my translation):
Hanc hedera intexit ditem fallacibus ulnis,In Thomas Sprat's translation:
Blanditiisque malis Arboricida necat.
Her treacherously the Ivy does embrace,Here is Cowley's own note, with my translation:
And kills the Tree with Kindness in her Face.
Arboricida. Verbum fictitium, sed satis ex analogia aliorum.See Otto Gradenwitz, Laterculi vocum Latinarum: voces Latinas et a fronte et a tergo ordinandas (Leipzig: S. Hirzel, 1904), pp. 282-283, for a list of Latin words ending in -cida, one of which is lignicida, and p. 330 for a list of words ending in -cidium.
Arboricida. A made-up word, but sufficiently analogous to others.
Agennius Urbicus, in Brian Campbell, The Writings of the Roman Land Surveyors: Introduction, Text, Translation and Commentary (London: Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies, 2000), pp. 70 (Latin) and 71 (translation):
in Italia autem multi crescente religione sacratissima Christiana lucos profanos sive templorum loca occupaverunt et serunt.On Agennius Urbicus see Schanz-Hosius, Geschichte der römischen Literatur, 4. Teil, 2. Band = Die Literatur des fünften und sechsten Jahrhunderts (München: C.H. Beck, 1920; rpt. 1971), § 1138, pp. 302-304.
Now, in Italy, as the most holy Christian religion increases, many people have taken over pagan groves or sites attached to temples, and now sow them.
Gregory the Great (540-604), Dialogues 2.8, tr. by Hilary Costello and Eoin de Bhaldraithe in Gregory the Great, The Life of St. Benedict, tr. (Petersham: St. Bede's Publications, 1993; rpt. 2003), p. 64:
The stronghold called Casinum is situated on the side of a high mountain, where a broad shelf of land forms the site. Behind this the mountain rises steeply for a distance of three miles, as if to rear its summit to the skies. On the top there was a very old temple and there, according to ancient customs among the heathens, Apollo was worshipped by the poor foolish natives of the rustic population. Sacred groves dedicated to demons grew all around the temple where a horde of pagans still took great pains to offer their sacrilegious sacrifices.The Latin:
As soon as he arrived, the man of God smashed up the idol, overturned the altar and felled the sacred trees. In the temple of Apollo itself he built an oratory to Blessed Martin, and on the site of the altar to Apollo he built an oratory to St. John.
Castrum namque quod Cassinum dicitur, in excelsi montis latere situm est, qui videlicet mons distenso sinu hoc idem castrum recepit, sed per tria millia in altum se subrigens, velut ad aera cacumen tendit: ubi vetustissimum fanum fuit, in quo ex antiquorum more gentilium a stulto rusticorum populo Apollo colebatur. Circumquaque etiam in cultu daemonum luci succreverant, in quibus adhuc eodem tempore infidelium insana multitudo sacrificiis sacrilegis insudabat.
Illuc itaque vir Dei perveniens, contrivit idolum, subvertit aram, succidit lucos, atque in ipso templo Apollinis oraculum beati Martini, ubi vero ara eiusdem Apollinis, fuit oraculum sancti Ioannis construxit.
succidit: succendit alii
Sermon of St. Eligius (588-660), Bishop of Noyon-Tournai, quoted in Dado (aka Audoen or Ouen or Owen), Life of St. Eligius 2.16, tr. Jo Ann McNamara:
Venerate no creature beyond God and his saints. Shun springs and arbors which they call sacred. You are forbidden to make the crook which they place on the crossroads and wherever you find one you should burn it with fire. For you must believe that you can be saved by no other art than the invocation and cross of Christ. For how will it be if groves where these miserable men make their devotions, are felled and the wood from them given to the furnace? See how foolish man is, to offer honor to insensible, dead trees and despise the precepts of God almighty.2.22:
Another day taking the road for necessary purposes, he came to a place not far from the royal estate at Compiègne. Weary from traveling, he turned into a certain colonus's field. There was an arbor of nut trees there, heavily laden with edible fruit. And when Eligius had rested a while, some of his servants went out and began to pick nuts from the trees for it was time for them to eat together. Rushing forward, the lord of the orchard loudly complained that his nuts were being stolen from him. Eligius called his men to him and softly and mildly soothed him saying: "Friend, don't be a nuisance to us because of this. If the boys took a little, there is much still remaining and I will give you money in satisfaction for anything that they have taken." But with swollen mind, spurning his mildness, he reviled him, taxing him closely with hard words. Thus Eligius with unruffled spirit, scolded his servants more harshly for what they had done and ordered them to give the man three gold pieces for the substance he had lost. Then, after the example of the Lord with the fig tree, he turned toward the orchard and ordered: "Since we were so attacked for you, nevermore till eternity shall you bear fruit." And, oh wonderful power of God, whose example was followed in this word, his virtue achieved the same effect. For after a little while the arbor dried up and remained permanently arid. So in this case he merited to follow the Lord's example, ordering the orchard with confidence, because he had put his whole faith in the Lord's words Who said, "He who believes in me, not only shall he do what I do but what is more it shall be done."Original Latin in Vita Eligii episcopi Noviomagensis, ed. B. Krutsch, in Monumenta Germaniae Historica, Scriptorum Rerum Merovingicarum Tomus IV (Hanover: Hahn, 1902), pp.669-742 (2.16 at pp. 707-708):
Nulli creaturae praeter Deum et sanctis eius venerationem exhibeatis; fontes vel arbores quos sacrivos vocant succidite; pedum similitudines, quos per bivios ponunt, fieri vetate, et ubi inveneritis, igne cremate. Per nullam aliam artem salvari vos credatis nisi per invocationem et crucem Christi. Nam illud quale est, quod si arbores illae, ubi miseri homines vota reddunt, ceciderint, nec ex eis ligna ad focum sibi deferunt? Et videte, quanta stultitia est hominum, si arbori insensibili et mortuae honorem inpendunt et Dei omnipotentis praecepta contempnunt.2.22 (pp. 713-714):
Una autem dierum iter necessarium carpens, devenit ad quendam locum haud longe a Conpendio regali, optimum praedium, et fatigatus ex itinere, divertit in agrum cuiusdam coloni; erat autem illi arbor magna nucarii onusta fructu vescibili. Cumque Eligius in diversorium quiesceret, egressi quidam ex ministris eius coeperunt ex praefata arbuscula avellere nuces; erat enim tempus, quo congrue vesci poterant. Accurrens autem concite dominus arbustae, causabatur procaciter nuces sibi subripere; quo Eligius conperto vocat ad se virum, et blande ac leniter eum demulcens, ait: 'Noli, amice, huiuscemodi ob causam molestus nobis existere, et si pauca pueri praesumpserunt, plurima tibi adhuc supersunt; nam et hoc quod attigerunt ego, data pecunia, tibi gratifice satisfaciam'. At ille tumida mente lenitatem eius spernens, duris eum amaricabat verbis, eadem crebrius taxans. Tunc Eligius animo inmutatus famulos quidem pro rei facto durius obiurgavit, homini vero pro substantiae damno tres aureos dari iussit; ad arbustam tamen conversus, nimirum salvatoris ficulneae imperantis exemplo usus, ait: 'Quoniam tantopere pro te lacescimur, numquam ex te ex hoc iam fructus nascatur in aeternum'. Et, o mira Domini potentia! cuius exemplum secutus fuerat in verbo, eiusdem et virtus subsequitur in effectu; nam post non longum spatium arefacta arbusta, sicca demum permanet in aevum. Merito igitur in hoc opere dominicum secutus exemplum, arbustae cum fiducia imperavit, qui fide plenissimat dominicam tenebat sententiam, qua dicitur, quia qui credit in me, non solum faciet ea quae ego facio, sed et maiora, inquit, faciet.
Council of Nantes (7th or 9th century?), c. 18, in Jacques Sirmond, ed. Concilia Antiqua Galliae (Paris, 1629; rpt. Aalen: Scientia, 1970), vol. 3, p. 607 (my translation):
Bishops and their clergy ought to struggle with the greatest zeal to cut down and burn trees consecrated to demons, which the common people worship and hold in such veneration that they dare not cut branch or shoot from them.For bibliography on the disputed existence and date of the Council of Nantes, see Bernadette Filotas, Pagan Survivals, Superstitions and Popular Cultures in Early Medieval Pastoral Literature (Toronto: Pontifical Institute of Mediaeval Studies, 2005 = Studies and Texts, 151), p. 367.
Summo studio decertare debent episcopi et eorum ministri, ut arbores demonibus consecratae quas vulgus colit, et in tanta veneratione habet, ut nec ramum vel surculum inde audeat amputare, radicitus excidantur atque comburantur.
Labels: arboricide
Scholars
Jasper Griffin, "Augustan Poetry and the Life of Luxury," in Latin Poets and Roman Life (London: Duckworth, 1985; rpt. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1986), pp. 1-31 (at 17):
The private life of the Latin love poets will have borne little resemblance to that of a modern scholar.William Butler Yeats, The Scholars:
Bald heads forgetful of their sins,
Old, learned, respectable bald heads
Edit and annotate the lines
That young men, tossing on their beds,
Rhymed out in love's despair
To flatter beauty's ignorant ear.
All shuffle there; all cough in ink;
All wear the carpet with their shoes;
All think what other people think;
All know the man their neighbour knows.
Lord, what would they say
Did their Catullus walk that way?
Bad Breath
Martial 3.17 (tr. Tony Harrison):
The tart passed round for sweet's so hotMartial 3.28 (tr. Paul Nixon):
no one touches it. No one, but NOT
Sabidius whose greed burns more.
He blows on it 1-2-3-4.
It's cool. Still no one touches it
Sabidius's breath turns all to shit.
Circumlata diu mensis scribilita secundis
urebat nimio saeva calore manus;
sed magis ardebat Sabidi gula: protinus ergo
sufflavit buccis terque quaterque suis.
illa quidem tepuit digitosque admittere visa est,
sed nemo potuit tangere: merda fuit.
"There's a horrible smell in poor Marius' ear."Related post: Halitosis.
You're surprised at the matter?
A coincidence, Nestor, escapes you, I fear —
That's just where you chatter.
Auriculam Mario graviter miraris olere.
tu facis hoc: garris, Nestor, in auriculam.
Tuesday, June 22, 2010
Jerome of Prague
In Theodor Hirsch et al., edd., Scriptores Rerum Prussicarum: Die Gesichtsquellen der preussischen Vorzeit bis zum Untergange der Ordensherrschaft, 4. Bd. (Leipzig, 1870), p. 239 = Aeneas Sylvius (Pope Pius II), Historia de Europa (Basel, 1551), c. XXVI, f. 417, there is the following account of missionary work in Lithuania by Jerome of Prague, who lived from 1379 to 1416:
Then he came to other peoples who worshipped forests sacred to devils and who considered one particular forest to be more worthy of worship than others. For several days, revealing the sacraments of our faith, he preached to this folk, and at last he ordered them to cut down the forest. Although people were present with axes, there was no one who dared to touch the holy wood with iron. Therefore Jerome, taking the lead, grabbed a two-headed axe and felled a certain tall tree. Then the crowd followed in eager emulation; some were cutting down the forest with saws, some with picks, some with axes. They reached the middle of the grove, where they thought that a very old oak, holy above all the others, was in particular the dwelling place of gods. For some time no one dared strike; finally one man, bolder than the others, upbraiding his comrades for being afraid to strike the wood (an inanimate thing), raised his axe and was planning to chop the tree, when he struck his thigh and fell down in a faint.The preceding rough translation is my own, because I couldn't find one by anyone else. Here is the Latin, divided into paragraphs by me:
The surrounding crowd was astonished — they wept, lamented, and accused Jerome of persuading them to violate the sacred home of the god. There was no longer anyone who dared to ply the axe. Thereupon Jerome, claiming that these were demonic illusions designed to bamboozle the eyes of the deceived crowd, ordered the man (whom I said fell down wounded) to get up, and he showed that the man wasn't harmed at all. Soon, with the aid of the crowd, he drove the axe against the tree, felled the huge mass with a loud crash, and cut down the entire grove.
In that region there were several other forests, considered holy by reason of the same superstition. While Jerome was hastening to them in order to cut them down, a large crowd of women approached Witold with weeping and wailing. They complained that their sacred grove had been cut down and the home of their god taken away, in which they had been accustomed to seek divine aid, and whence they had obtained rain and sun. They no longer knew where to seek the god, because Jerome and his followers had taken away the god's dwelling. There were other, smaller groves, in which gods were accustomed to be worshipped, but Jerome wanted to destroy these, too — he was introducing certain strange rites to uproot their ancestral customs. The women therefore asked and beseeched Witold not to allow the places of their ancestral rites and their ceremonies to be abolished. Men also followed the women and claimed they could not endure the new religion; they said they would rather leave their land and their ancestral hearths than abandon the religion they had received from their forefathers. Moved by this circumstance and fearing a popular uprising, Witold wished Christ, rather than himself, to be without followers. He recalled the letters in which he had told the chiefs of his provinces to obey Jerome, and ordered Jerome to depart from the territory.
Postremo alios populos adiit, qui sylvas daemonibus consecratas venerabantur et inter alias unam cultu digniorem putavere. Praedicavit huic genti pluribus diebus fidei nostrae aperiens sacramenta, denique ut sylvam succideret imperavit; ubi populus cum securibus affuit, nemo erat, qui sacrum lignum ferro contingere auderet. Prior itaque Hieronymus assumpta bipenni excellentem quandam arborem detruncavit. Tum secuta multitudo alacri certamine; alii serris alii dolabris alii securibus sylvam deiiciebant. Ventura erat ad medium nemoris, ubi quercum vetustissimam et ante omnes arbores religione sacram et quam potissime sedem [Deorum?] esse putabant. Percutere aliquamdiu nullus praesumpsit; postremo ut est alter altero audacior increpans quidam socios, qui lignum rem insensatam percutere formidarent, elevata bipenni magno ictu cum arborem caedere arbitraretur, tibiam suam percussit atque in terram semianimis cecidit.Jerome of Prague's missionary work ultimately didn't redeem him in the eyes of church authorities. He was burned at the stake as a heretic.
Attonita circum turba flere, conqueri, Hieronymum accusare, qui sacram Dei domum violari suasisset, neque jam quisquam erat, qui ferrum exercere auderet. Tum Hieronymus illusiones daemonum esse affirmans, quae deceptae plebis oculos fascinarent, surgere quem cecidisse vulneratum diximus imperavit et nulla in parte laesum ostendit et mox ad arborem adacto ferro adiuvante multitudine ingens onus cum magno fragore prostravit totumque nemus succidit.
Erant in ea regione plures sylvae pari religione sacrae, ad quas dum Hieronymus amputandas pergit mulierum ingens numerus plorans atque eiulans Vitoldum adit, sacrum lucum succisum queritur et domum Dei ademptam, in qua divinam opem petere consuessent, inde pluvias inde soles obtinuisse; nescire iam quo in loco Deum quaerant, cui domicilium abstulerint; esse aliquos minores lucos, in queis Dii coli soleant, eos quoque delere Hieronymum velle, qui nova quaedam sacra introducens patrium morem extirpet; rogare igitur atque obtestari, ne maiorum religionum loca et caeremonias auferri sinat. Sequuntur et viri mulieres nec se ferre posse novum cuitum asserunt, relinquere potius terram et patrios lares quam religionem a maioribus acceptam dicunt. Motus ea re Vitoldus veritusque populorum tumultum Christo potius quam sibi deesse plebem voluit. Revocatisque literis, quas praesidibus provinciarum declarat jubens parere Hieronymo, hominem ex provincia decedere iussit.
Labels: arboricide
A Lonely Hut
John Clare, note from Peterborough MS A57:
John George Brown, Camp in the Maine Wood, No.3 (1879)
Related posts:
An almost boundless solitary heath with its stumpy bushes & a lonely hut built up of brush wood & thacked with fern would to my feelings be more delightful to meet with then a crowded City full of mighty streets triumphal arches & marble templesJohn Clare, The Woods:
I love to roam the woods
Oft patted by the boughs
That meet from either side
& form an arch of leaves
Till hidden as it where from all the world
I stand & muse upon the pleasant scene
I seem to be myself
The only one that treads
The earth at such a time
So vacant is the mass
That spreads around me one hugh sea of leaves
& intertwining grains of thickest shades
No human eye is visible
No human sound attracts
The ear—but musing solitude
One unembodied thought
Thinks the heart into stillness as the world
Was left behind for somthing green & new
& lonely—& Ive thought
In such a spot to build
An hermitage or hut
With books & leisure left
How sweet t'would be but then again
I've turned to my old home & felt it vain
Yet sure a hut close thatched
Chafed by oerleaning boughs
In such a place when night
Dark on the crowd of trees
Found us locked in beside a blazing fire
Might give us happiness & pleasing fears
Fear books can give us
When we read strange tales
Of dwellers in the depths
Of earths untrodden shades
Where woods surround lone huts impassable
& nought lives near them but the hope of heaven

Related posts:
Monday, June 21, 2010
Improve the Summer
Henry David Thoreau, Journal (July 23, 1851):
George Inness, Summer Morning
Newer› ‹Older
The wind has fairly blown me outdoors; the elements were so lively and active, and I so sympathized with them, that I could not sit while the wind went by. And I am reminded that we should especially improve the summer to live out-of-doors. When we may so easily, it behooves us to break up this custom of sitting in the house, for it is but a custom, and I am not sure that it has the sanction of common sense. A man no sooner gets up than he sits down again. Fowls leave their perch in the morning, and beasts their lairs, unless they are such as go abroad only by night. The cockerel does not take up a new perch in the barn, and he is the embodiment of health and common sense. Is the literary man to live always or chiefly sitting in a chamber through which nature enters by a window only? What is the use of the summer?

